Testimony in Opposition to H.1234, “An Act Establishing Portable Benefit Accounts for App-Based Drivers”

October 6, 2021

Chairman Murphy, Chairman Crighton, and distinguished members of the Joint Committee on Financial Services:

Thank you for the opportunity to testify on this important matter. I write in opposition to House Bill 1234. As Attorney General Attorney General Maura Healey has maintained, a company like Uber or Lyft assigns tasks to their workers via cell phone app should not excuse them from providing the full benefits and protections due under Massachusetts Wage and Hours Laws, including those granted by the Wage Act, Minimum Wage Law, Overtime Law, Earned Sick Time Law, and Anti-Retaliation Statutes.

The bill in question would create a loophole in employment law, enabling some companies to avoid their obligations to their workers. The benefits and protections in this bill are unambiguously weaker than those required for other employees. The bill’s minimum wage assertions are deeply compromised by excluding so many of the hours work performed.

A review by the University of California Berkeley determined that the arrangement sought by Uber and Lyft would fail to deliver on its promises. A majority of Massachusetts drivers could earn as little as the equivalent of a $4.82 wage. For the minority of drivers who would qualify for a health care stipend, they could earn the equivalent of $6.74 per hour. Drivers would not be paid for the time between rides waiting for assignments. Nor would drivers be fully compensated for expenses like gas and insurance.

The threat to labor standards is not limited to wages. A similar arrangement companies put in place in California reportedly provides health insurance to only a small minority of rideshare or delivery drivers, with coverage worst for drivers of color. Workers would lack strong paid family leave, unemployment insurance and worker’s compensation, the right to join a union, and employee protections against sexual harassment and racial discrimination at work. Leaving workers out of social insurance pools such as unemployment insurance will ultimately undermine these programs and their financing.

The legislation would also encourage other employers to introduce app-based interfaces with their employees to avoid paying for worker benefits and protections. The proliferation of remote work arrangements and workplace task management platforms make it plausible that virtually any employee could become misclassified as an employee with the aid of an app-based interferace.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
Phineas Baxandall, Ph.D., Senior Analyst
Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center

Latest

Fundamentally Flawed: 62F Formula Overstates “Excess” by $1.4 Billion

The $2.9 billion estimate of 62F “excess tax collections” recently certified by the State Auditor overstates these net Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 collections by $1.4 billion. The problem is not that the Auditor miscalculated but that the calculation as stipulated in the 62F statute fails to account for situations where taxes are received by the Commonwealth in one fiscal year, but corresponding, offsetting tax credits are not applied until the following fiscal year. This is one of the many fundamental flaws in the 1986 tax cap law (referred to as “62F”).

Read More →

Where Might Home Sales Be Subject to the Fair Share Amendment? A Local Breakdown

In the majority of Massachusetts cities and towns, no homes sold for a net gain of $1 million or more, meaning they wouldn’t be subject to any additional taxes under the Fair Share Amendment.

Read More →

62F Credits Benefit the Rich

The “tax cap law,” or what is known as “62F,” sets an artificial limit on how much tax revenue Massachusetts can collect, regardless of the current needs of the Commonwealth. This law in effect transfers to higher income households tax revenue paid by lower income households and does nothing to improve racial or economic equity in our state.

Read More →
Scroll to Top

Get news from Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center in your inbox.