Current Estate Tax Proposals Would Give Largest Benefits to Wealthiest Estates; Alternative Method Would Fix This Problem

The tax on inherited estates is Massachusetts’ only tax that directly reduces wealth inequality. Although the pandemic has highlighted disparities between rich and poor families, the Governor and some in the Legislature have proposed changes to the estate tax that would largely benefit the state’s wealthiest households. These changes would double the current no-tax threshold from $1 million to $2 million, and for larger estates would subtract $2 million from the amount subject to taxation before applying tax rates. 

The Governor’s proposal would cost the Commonwealth’s budget $231 million annually. When the Department of Revenue looked at Massachusetts’ richest estates – those worth over $1 million – they found that the Governor’s proposed cut to the estate tax would deliver 63 percent of the tax benefit to the top 40 percent of that group. 

Lawmakers often talk about changes to the estate tax as an attempt to help beneficiaries of smaller taxable estates. But the approach favored by the Governor, which many lawmakers seem to support, would provide the biggest tax breaks to the largest estates. A $12 million estate would receive a tax benefit of $320,000 – more than three times the benefit provided to a $2 million estate.   

It doesn’t have to work this way. If lawmakers want to reduce taxes on the intergenerational transfer of wealth up to $2 million, there are simple alternatives that would do so without providing even bigger benefits to the wealthiest of the state’s wealthiest households. These alternatives would also retain more state revenue that could be spent on other public priorities. 

A quick look at how the estate tax works makes it clear why the biggest estates receive the biggest benefit from the Governor’s current proposal. 

The estate tax is a graduated tax. It applies lower rates on the first taxable dollars and then applies increasingly higher marginal rates to increasingly larger estates. The tax rates max out at 16 percent on the amount of any estate over $10 million. The Governor’s proposal – which many lawmakers are also mulling over – would exclude $2 million from taxes off the top end of the estate. This means that there is $2 million less subject to the higher brackets. This is a tax benefit worth far more to larger estates.   

A simple alternative would exempt the first $2 million from estate taxes, but then apply the same marginal tax rates as at present to additional amounts of estate. Estates larger than $2 million would receive the same amount in a tax cut as a $2 million estate (see chart). 

An even simpler alternative would be to only increase the no-tax threshold to $2 million. Estates below $2 million would pay no tax, and estates above that mark would pay the same as they do today. There would be a large tax difference for estates just above and below the no-tax threshold, which might motivate some people with estates near the threshold to make charitable contributions to ensure their estate is valued below $2 million.  

Moreover, if lawmakers seek to target tax relief to estates mainly consisting of a high-value home, they could target their additional $1 million tax cut to apply only to a person’s primary residence or only by the same percentage that the home is of the estate. If these are the people that lawmakers are trying to help, they can design their policies to match those goals. 

Latest

What is the Actual State Cost of MassHealth in State Fiscal Year 2025?

This brief looks beyond the budget totals to help stakeholders better understand the actual state cost of MassHealth by accounting for the state and federal ...
Read More →

Job Opening – Housing Policy Analyst

MassBudget is seeking a housing policy analyst to focus on researching and analyzing housing policy across the Commonwealth, with associated activities to advocate for policy ...
Read More →

With Fair Share Dollars, Senate Ways and Means Proposes Bold Improvements, Though Problems with Student Opportunity Act Remain

On May 7th, the Senate Ways and Means (SWM) Committee released its proposed budget for the Fiscal Year 2025. Like last month’s House budget proposal, ...
Read More →
Scroll to Top

Get news from Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center in your inbox.